ships icon

Annuity vs drawdown: Which pension option should I choose?

Advertisement

A woman and child gardening

At a glance

  • An annuity is a product designed to give you a guaranteed income when you retire. The majority are for life but there are annuities which run over a set period.
  • Drawdown is where you withdraw funds from your pension pot to live on and keep the rest invested.
  • Both annuities and drawdown funds will be treated as taxable income.

Those approaching retirement may be starting to think about how to secure the right kind of income from their pension pot. For many retirees, the two key options will be purchasing an annuity or opting for income drawdown, but which one is right for you?

It’s a wholly personal decision and there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but we’ve broken down a few things to help you make the right decision for you and your finances.

What is the difference between an annuity and pension drawdown?

An annuity and pension drawdown can both be used to secure an income in retirement, but the ways they do that are very different. Let’s take a look at each in turn.

What is an annuity?

An annuity is a specially-designed product that can give you a guaranteed income in retirement. It’s purchased when you retire by using the money built up in your pension and will provide a regular income every month, thereby helping you maintain a decent lifestyle in retirement.

The key thing to remember with an annuity is that, once you’ve purchased it, you’ll have it for life – whether that’s another five years or 50 – and because your pension pot is essentially sold to the annuity provider, it cannot form part of your estate.

The downside of this is that, if you died after five years, your annuity provider would get to keep the rest of your pension pot (unless this was during a guarantee period or you set up death benefits or Value Protection), which could potentially be a significant sum that your beneficiaries would never get to see.

On the other hand, if you lived for another 50 years, you’d probably be on to a winner as your pot would have likely “run out” years earlier, and so the annuity provider would be paying out money they didn’t expect to. Find out more about annuities.

What is pension drawdown?

Pension drawdown, also known as income drawdown, allows you to keep your pension invested and withdraw a certain amount from your pot on a regular basis, which means your remaining pot could continue to benefit from investment growth while still being accessible. Like an annuity, the income you take will be taxed in the same way as employment income.

A key benefit is that, when you die, your estate will benefit from any remaining money from your pension pot, unlike with an annuity where any unused funds can be lost. There may be a tax liability for your beneficiaries depending on what age you are when you die, but there’ll still be money to pass on. Find out more about how pension drawdown works.

 

Drawdown vs. annuity

  Annuity Drawdown
Income Guaranteed for life Not guaranteed
Security Completely secure – payments are made for life No security – money could run out if too much is withdrawn from the pot each year
Flexibility None Income can be adjusted as needed
Management No management required You remain in control of your pension pot and all withdrawals so will need to manage it effectively
Investment risk None The remaining amount invested in your pot is still subject to investment risk (but also the potential for growth)
Inheritance Can’t normally be inherited unless protection was built in at the outset Unused funds will form part of your estate and so can be inherited, but tax liabilities may come into play

 

Find a financial adviser near you

Find a qualified, independent and regulated financial adviser in your area to help you make the right decisions about your financial future. A free service, quickly connect to over 27,000 experts with the help of Unbiased.co.uk.

 

Advantages of buying an annuity

  • Your income is guaranteed for life. This means that even if you “outlive” your pension pot, the annuity provider has to keep making payments until you die.
  • You may be able to get a larger income if you have certain health or lifestyle conditions. This is what’s known as an enhanced annuity, and could result in a much higher monthly payout.
  • You may be able to pass on your unused pension pot if you have death benefits built in.
  • There’s no investment risk as your pot is essentially handed over to the annuity company, so your monthly payments will never fluctuate and you can never lose your money.

Disadvantages of buying an annuity

  • There’s no option to review your choices later – once you’ve purchased an annuity, it’s fixed and normally cannot be changed.
  • In most cases, if you die shortly after taking out the annuity your remaining pension pot will be lost and your beneficiaries cannot inherit (unless you build in certain protections beforehand).
  • Income received is treated as employment income, and so will be taxed at your usual rate.

It might be worth considering an annuity if you want guaranteed financial security for the rest of your life. It can help you budget more effectively as you’ll know exactly what you’ve got coming in, and if you plan in advance you may still be able to leave an inheritance as well.

Advantages of pension drawdown

  • You remain in control of your pension pot. You can choose how much to withdraw and when, offering a more flexible solution and income that can be adjusted according to your circumstances.
  • Your pot remains invested, and so has the chance to continue growing in value if the funds perform well.
  • Any money remaining in your pension pot at the time of death will form part of your estate and so can be passed on to your beneficiaries (though bear in mind that tax charges may apply)

Disadvantages of pension drawdown

  • There's the risk that you could literally empty your pension pot if you withdraw too much, leaving you with a much reduced income in later years.
  • As your pot remains invested, there’s the risk it could decrease in value if the funds you invested in don’t perform well.
  • Income will be treated as employment income and taxed at your nominal rate.

It might be worth considering pension drawdown if you have a large enough pot that can provide a suitable income without running out too soon, or if you simply want more flexibility over your finances and future inheritance.

Drawdown or annuity: Which is best?

As with so many financial decisions, there's no easy answer. The 'Catch 22' is that an annuity becomes better value the longer you live, but over a shorter term will not pay you as much income, and there may not be anything to leave to beneficiaries either. While with pension drawdown there’s the risk that you’ll run out of money during retirement, but it offers a lot more flexibility and the chance to leave a greater inheritance.

The choice you make will depend a lot on your circumstances, your health, your finances and even what you conceive your pension as being for: is it to provide an income in your retirement, to leave a financial legacy for your family, or a combination? That decision comes entirely down to your own individual circumstances and preferences, but it’s always worth seeking advice so you can discuss the options and come to a decision that works for you.

Advertisement Seasonal Banner Seasonal Banner

Annuity and drawdown combined

You don’t always need to choose an annuity or drawdown – what about a combination of the two? There’s nothing to say that you can’t use a portion of your pension pot to buy an annuity and keep the rest invested for drawdown, giving you the security of a guaranteed income with the flexibility to increase it should you need, essentially giving the best of both worlds.

Can I change from drawdown to annuity?

Yes – opting for drawdown means you’re in complete control of your pension pot, so if you decide to purchase an annuity at a later date, you absolutely can.

Can you change an annuity to drawdown?

No. Buying an annuity typically means you’re locked in for life, so you normally won’t have the option of switching back to drawdown later (unless you opt for a fixed term annuity; discuss the options with your adviser).

Moneyfacts tip Image of Leanne Macardle

Choosing how you will take your income in retirement will possibly be the biggest financial decision of your life, so be sure to enlist the services of a good financial adviser and always shop around to maximise your income, no matter what route you choose to go down.

Disclaimer: This information is intended solely to provide guidance and is not financial advice. Moneyfacts will not be liable for any loss arising from your use or reliance on this information. If you are in any doubt, Moneyfacts recommends you obtain independent financial advice.

A woman and child gardening
Back to top image

Moneyfactscompare.co.uk will never contact you by phone to sell you any financial product. Any calls like this are not from Moneyfacts. Emails sent by Moneyfactscompare.co.uk will always be from news@moneyfacts-news.co.uk. Be ScamSmart.

Moneyfactscompare.co.uk will never contact you by phone to sell you any financial product. Any calls like this are not from Moneyfacts. Emails sent by Moneyfactscompare.co.uk will always be from news@moneyfacts-news.co.uk. Be ScamSmart.